Site Navigation

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
FAQ

Always Fresh Bakery

"Homemade Donuts And Pretzels Brought To You By Your Amish Neighbors!"

About Us

Always Fresh Bakery is a beloved local bakery that has been serving the communities of Greensburg, Osgood, Rushville, Connersville, Batesville, Napoleon, Shelbyville, and Westport since 2023. Our specialty lies in crafting delicious baked goods, donuts, and catering services for all occasions. In addition, we offer a delectable assortment of pretzels, chicken sandwiches, fish, bread, pies, cheesecakes, cinnamon rolls, cakes, potato salad, hamburgers, pasta salad, and more. Join us for our renowned Fish Fridays, enjoy a scrumptious breakfast, lunch, or dinner, or plan your next event with our delightful catering options. Let us make your gatherings memorable with our baked goods orders, buffet services, pie orders, and convenient party reservations. Come experience the freshness and quality that defines Always Fresh Bakery.

Areas Served

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Bakery
Donuts
Catering

Our Services include:

Breakfast: Start your morning with our fresh, homemade breakfasts featuring warm pastries, and made-to-order favorites.
Lunch: Enjoy a delicious and satisfying lunch with sandwiches, salads, daily specials, and fresh bakery sides crafted in-house.
Dinner: Relax and unwind with a comforting dinner menu made from scratch, offering homestyle meals and fresh-baked goodness.
Buffet: Our buffet features a rotating selection of freshly prepared dishes, baked specialties, and customer favorites—perfect for every appetite.
Fish Fridays: Join us every Friday for our signature Fish Fry, served hot, crispy, and perfectly seasoned with all your favorite sides.
Baked Good Orders: Place your order for fresh-baked treats made with quality ingredients and care.
Pie Orders: Order one of our homemade pies, baked fresh and available in a variety of classic flavors—perfect for holidays, gatherings, or any occasion.
Parties: Celebrate your next event with us! We offer delicious food, baked goods, and a welcoming space ideal for birthdays, gatherings, and special occasions.
Reservations: Reserve a table for your next visit to ensure quick seating and the best dining experience with friends and family.
Events: We host special events throughout the year featuring seasonal menus, themed meals, and community gatherings you won’t want to miss.

Our Products include:

Pretzels
Chicken Sandwiches
Fish
Bread
Pies
Cheesecakes
Cinnamon Rolls
Cakes
Potato Salad
Hamburgers
Pasta Salad

Testimonials

On 4/12/2026 Adam had this to say:
Great little hidden local hidden gem. Enjoy the great food. It's a nice change from what I am used to. The cheesecake is unbelievably good. Testimonial written by Adam on this site.

On 4/10/2026 Dillon Dunn had this to say:
Stopped in here the other morning and was very pleased that I did. The ladies behind the counter were welcoming and had some recommendations when I didn't know what I wanted. They offer a breakfast bar, their fantastic soft pretzels, and all kinds of other made-to-order goodies. They also have some ready made breads and treats in the store. I got a breakfast burrito and a pretzel for later and they were both great. Definitely going to have to come back to try some of their lunch options!

On 4/9/2026 TIMOTHEY ORBIK had this to say:
The staff are really nice the food is amazing and overall I will be going back they've got really good prices everything is homemade the pretzels are huge they're like almost a pound and they're only $7 and you get a cheese cup with it 10 out of 10 I would definitely recommend this to anyone who comes to town and is looking for a place to stop and get something to eat Testimonial written by TIMOTHEY ORBIK on this site.

On 3/28/2026 Reaghann J had this to say:
Purchased a sugar cookie from them at a local vendor event. Best Cookie I’ve ever had, and super cheap! Totally check them out!!!! Testimonial written by Reaghann J on this site.

On 3/20/2026 Anonymous had this to say:
Wonderful service and great homemade goods! Testimonial submitted anonymously directly to this site.

Contact Us

Always Fresh Bakery
1917 N Broadway St Greensburg, IN 47240
Phone: (812) 593-6555
Email: jrssn@hotmail.com

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Personal Checks, Debit Cards, Discover, MasterCard, PayPal, Visa, Venmo, Zelle, Cash App

Our Hours

Monday: 7:00 AM - 1:30 PM
Tuesday: 7:00 AM - 1:30 PM
Wednesday: 7:00 AM - 1:30 PM
Thursday: 7:00 AM - 1:30 PM
Friday: 7:00 AM - 1:30 PM
Saturday: 9:00 AM - 1:30 PM

FAQ

What types of baked goods do you offer?

We offer an extensive menu of freshly baked goods, including donuts, pretzels, breads, pies, cheesecakes, cinnamon rolls, and cakes. All items are prepared with quality ingredients and made fresh daily to ensure the best possible taste and texture.

Do you offer breakfast, lunch, and dinner?

Yes! Always Fresh Bakery is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, offering a variety of meals such as chicken sandwiches, fish, hamburgers, pasta salad, potato salad, and more. No matter the time of day, we have something delicious ready for you.

What is “Fish Fridays”?

Our famous Fish Fridays are a community favorite! Each Friday, we serve a special selection of freshly prepared fish dishes—perfect for dine‑in or takeout. Many customers make it a weekly tradition.

Do you offer catering services?

Yes! Always Fresh Bakery provides full catering services for gatherings of all sizes. From corporate meetings to birthday parties to family celebrations, we can supply baked goods, entrées, sides, and full buffet setups tailored to your event.

Do you offer buffet-style service for events?

Yes. Our buffet services are a popular option for birthdays, reunions, celebrations, business events, and more. We provide a variety of hot and cold dishes, along with baked goods and dessert options, depending on your needs.

Can I place custom baked goods or pie orders?

Absolutely. We accept custom baked goods orders, including pies, cakes, specialty desserts, and bulk items for events. Advance notice is recommended so we can craft your order fresh and exactly to your specifications.

Can I reserve space for a party or event?

Yes! Always Fresh Bakery offers party reservations so you can host your gathering in our welcoming environment. Our team can help coordinate food, dessert tables, and event details to ensure a smooth, enjoyable experience.